Aster Pilot 001 — Execution Record

Pilot: Aster Pilot 001
Pilot Version: 1.0
Layer: Evaluator Only
Record Status: EMPTY — NOT EXECUTED

This document defines the execution record for Aster Pilot 001.

It must preserve what actually occurred during the pilot separately from later evaluation and interpretation.

The record must not be rewritten to make an execution conform to the intended protocol.

1. Run Identification

Run ID:
Execution date:
Experimental condition:
Trajectory ID:
Operator:

2. Model Configuration

Model:
Model version / identifier:
Provider:
Configuration:
Context limit, if known:
Reasoning mode / effort, if configurable:

Tools available:

Retrieval or search capabilities:

Other relevant execution settings:

If a setting cannot be determined reliably, record:

UNKNOWN

Do not infer missing configuration values.

3. Initial Artifact State

Record the exact project state supplied at the beginning of the run.

Starting reference state: G0

Agent-visible artifacts:

requirements.md
architecture.md
operations.md
decisions.md
open-issues.md

Artifact version / commit:

Additional artifacts supplied:

Evaluator-only artifacts exposed to agent: NONE

Any deviation must be recorded before continuing.

4. Initial Instructions

Record the exact instructions supplied to the agent before reconstruction.

Instruction:

Do not summarize or normalize the original instruction.

5. Reconstruction — AI-A

Agent: AI-A

Conversational state from previous agent: NONE

Reconstruction start:
Reconstruction end:

Raw Reconstruction Output

The raw output must be preserved before evaluation.

Reconstruction Evaluation

Property	Classification	Evidence / Notes
P01
P02
P03
P04
P05
P06
P07
P08
P09
P10
P11
P12

Allowed initial classifications:

Recovered
Partially recovered
Incorrect
Not recovered
Not assessable

Relationship Reconstruction

Relationship	Classification	Evidence / Notes
R01
R02
R03

6. T1 — Documentation Consolidation

Instruction Supplied

Pre-Transformation State

Artifact snapshot / commit:

Raw Agent Output

Files Changed

Post-Transformation State

Artifact snapshot / commit:

Local Task Evaluation

Criterion	Result	Evidence / Notes
Operational explanation consolidated in `operations.md`
Redundant operational detail reduced in `architecture.md`
Required architectural relationships retained
No contradictory duplicate description remains

Allowed classifications:

Satisfied
Partially satisfied
Not satisfied
Not assessable

Conservation Evaluation

Record P01–P12 individually according to the evaluation framework.

Property	Result	Failure Label(s)	Evidence / Notes
P01
P02
P03
P04
P05
P06
P07
P08
P09
P10
P11
P12

Allowed conservation classifications:

Preserved
Degraded
Violated
Not assessable

7. T2 — Optional Batch Compression

Instruction Supplied

Pre-Transformation State

Artifact snapshot / commit:

Raw Agent Output

Files Changed

Post-Transformation State

Artifact snapshot / commit:

Local Task Evaluation

Criterion	Result	Evidence / Notes
Optional batch compression capability introduced
Capability documented in `architecture.md`
Capability documented in `operations.md`
Compression remains optional rather than mandatory

Expected Authorized Transition

[ \varnothing \rightarrow P13 ]

P13 Evaluation

Result:
Evidence:

Conservation Evaluation

Evaluate the valid pre-existing reference properties independently from creation of P13.

Property	Result	Failure Label(s)	Evidence / Notes
P01
P02
P03
P04
P05
P06
P07
P08
P09
P10
P11
P12

8. Replacement Event

Record the replacement event exactly as executed.

Outgoing agent: AI-A
Incoming agent: AI-B
Replacement time:

Conversational state transferred: NONE

Persistent artifacts transferred:

Other information transferred:

Tools available to AI-B:

Any information received by AI-B beyond the permitted persistent project state must be recorded as a protocol deviation.

9. Reconstruction — AI-B

AI-B must reconstruct the project from the persistent artifacts available after T2.

Reconstruction start:
Reconstruction end:

Raw Reconstruction Output

Reconstruction Evaluation

The applicable expected reference state at this stage is:

[ G_2 ]

including P13 if T2 produced the expected authorized transition.

Evaluation of the agent-produced trajectory must remain distinguishable from evaluation against the expected reference state.

Property	Classification	Evidence / Notes
P01
P02
P03
P04
P05
P06
P07
P08
P09
P10
P11
P12
P13

Relationship Reconstruction

Relationship	Classification	Evidence / Notes
R01
R02
R03

10. T3 — Transmission Interval Change

Instruction Supplied

Pre-Transformation State

Artifact snapshot / commit:

Raw Agent Output

Files Changed

Post-Transformation State

Artifact snapshot / commit:

Expected Authorized Transition

[ P02:10\ minutes\rightarrow15\ minutes ]

Local Task Evaluation

Criterion	Result	Evidence / Notes
Normal interval established as 15 minutes
Relevant project documentation updated consistently
No active statement retains 10 minutes as normal interval

Conservation Evaluation

P02 is evaluated through local task success because its semantic change is authorized.

Evaluate the remaining valid properties for conservation.

Property	Result	Failure Label(s)	Evidence / Notes
P01
P03
P04
P05
P06
P07
P08
P09
P10
P11
P12
P13

11. T4 — Configurable Retention Policy

Instruction Supplied

Pre-Transformation State

Artifact snapshot / commit:

Raw Agent Output

Files Changed

Post-Transformation State

Artifact snapshot / commit:

Expected Authorized Transition

[ \varnothing\rightarrow P14 ]

while:

[ P11=UNRESOLVED ]

remains valid.

Local Task Evaluation

Criterion	Result	Evidence / Notes
Configurable retention-policy capability introduced
Capability documented in `architecture.md`
`open-issues.md` updated consistently
No specific retention duration selected

P14 Evaluation

Result:
Evidence:

Conservation Evaluation

Property	Result	Failure Label(s)	Evidence / Notes
P01
P02 (15 minutes)
P03
P04
P05
P06
P07
P08
P09
P10
P11
P12
P13

12. Failure Labels

Where applicable, use only the predefined labels:

Omission
Contradiction
Unauthorized modification
Relationship loss
Authority or status error
Premature closure
Historical distortion

A label must not be added merely because an output is undesirable.

If an observed failure cannot be represented adequately by this taxonomy, record it separately as:

UNCLASSIFIED OBSERVED FAILURE

Do not modify the frozen taxonomy during the run.

13. Protocol Deviations

Record every known deviation.

ID	Stage	Deviation	Reason	Potential Effect

If none occurred, record:

NONE OBSERVED

14. Ground-Truth Issues

Record any possible defect discovered in the frozen reference material.

ID	Property / Rule	Issue	Discovery Stage	Affected Evaluation

Do not silently repair the ground truth during the run.

15. Evaluator Record

Evaluator ID:
Evaluation date:
Condition visible to evaluator: YES / NO
Research expectation visible to evaluator: YES / NO

Independent second evaluation performed: YES / NO

If yes:

Second evaluator ID:

Disagreements recorded separately: YES / NO

16. Raw Record Integrity

Confirm whether the following have been preserved:

Record	Preserved
Initial artifacts
Reconstruction AI-A
T1 raw output
Post-T1 artifacts
T2 raw output
Post-T2 artifacts
Replacement record
Reconstruction AI-B
T3 raw output
Post-T3 artifacts
T4 raw output
Final artifacts
Tool interactions, where available
Model/configuration metadata
Protocol deviations

17. Pilot Methodological Outcome

Complete only after execution and evaluation.

This section concerns the viability of the experimental method.

It is not a test of the broader research hypothesis.

Evaluate whether Pilot 001 demonstrated that:

reconstruction could be observed;
reconstruction could be evaluated against frozen properties;
local task success could be separated from conservation;
authorized semantic change could be distinguished from degradation;
deliberately unresolved state could be evaluated;
agent replacement could be executed without conversational transfer;
project-state trajectories could be preserved for audit;
the evaluation categories were sufficiently usable.

Methodological outcome:

Observed limitations:

Required protocol revisions:

Interpretation Boundary

Do not convert Pilot 001 observations into claims that:

long-horizon AI generally degrades project state;
a particular representation is superior;
agent replacement causes degradation;
Operational Project Alignment has been validated;
Horizonte has been validated.

Pilot 001 is a methodological pilot.

Its primary result is whether the proposed experimental procedure can be executed and evaluated coherently.

Record Status

Execution: NOT STARTED
Evaluation: NOT STARTED
Pilot conclusion: NONE